Make no
mistake about it, the Hobby Lobby lawsuit before the United States
Supreme Court is about more than birth control rights for women.
On the
surface, the question before the High Court is whether or not a
company can deny contraception coverage to women based on religious
beliefs. In other words, the Green family which owns Hobby Lobby
says forcing them to provide health insurance to employees with
contraceptive riders goes against their religion and they should not
be forced to do it.
Further,
the Green family says that since Hobby Lobby is their business, their
family religious beliefs should prevail for their corporate entity as
well.
In other
words, “my company/my house, I can do what I damn well please!”
Maybe.
What you
do in your house is usually your business. Private.
Your
company however, is a different matter. Or used to be until Citizens
United four years ago. Citizens United was a very bad Supreme Court
decision that granted corporations personhood rights equal to people,
meaning corporations have the same rights as people in the public
arena.
In the
four years of its existence, the Citizens United creation has become
a 21st century Frankenstein monster of SUPCO making.
US Supreme Court Justices |
If
successful, the Hobby Lobby lawsuit will give that Frankenstein
monster the right to exercise religious beliefs against anyone or
anything that dares to darken their corporate door.
Think
Arizona Law HB1062 vetoed by the governor a few weeks ago on
steroids, and in force nationwide.
It is
not just about birth control. This lawsuit is about the right to
impose personally held beliefs onto people within the public arena.
On any given day, you could walk into an ice cream store and be
denied service because the guy behind the counter doesn't like your
haircut/hair color/shoes/ skin color...
Whatever,
doesn't matter, their personally held belief about you prevails,
legally.
People
who don't like Black people, or women, or lesbians, or Muslims or
Jews wouldn't have to serve or wait on them or even allow them inside
their establishments simply because they can.
This is
what the Hobby Lobby lawsuit is all about.
The
right for bigots to legally discriminate and get away with it.
There is
no way to know how the High Court will handle this lawsuit. They
upheld Obamacare which seemingly created the situation, elevating
women to equality in healthcare with men, while at the same time,
giving us the very opposite leaning Citizens United by a narrow 5-4
decision.
Extended
oral arguments will be heard today with a decision expected just
prior to the June recess.
Um, I just noticed that Ruth appears separated from the rest of the Supremes. Should I read something into that?
ReplyDelete